Explore United States Fire Island

Gay bars and clubs in Fire Island

Ferries, tea dances and two car-free hamlets of pure summer.

3 clubs2 bars2 restaurants2 hotels2 beaches

Map and all 13 places

Updated November 2026

Fire Island is a thin barrier island off Long Island, and its two gay hamlets are made for summer. Cherry Grove is car-free and has 8 of our places, with Cherry Grove Beach a gay destination since the 1940s. The Grove Hotel is the heart of things, an adults-only LGBTQ+ boutique hotel with a pool, a bar and the Ice Palace club.

Ice Palace brings drag, theme parties and the Miss Fire Island pageant, in summer season only. Cherry's on the Bay does drag shows most nights in season, a piano bar and weekend drag brunch. The Arts Project of Cherry Grove, founded in 1948, stages theater, drag and art shows at the historic Community House.

A short hop away, Fire Island Pines has a style of its own. The Blue Whale is where the Pines tea dance began in 1966 and still hosts daily Low Tea. Pavilion is home to High Tea and show tune Sundays, Sip-n-Twirl picks up late on its rooftop deck and The Canteen keeps you caffeinated by day.

Fire Island gay bar passportHow many of the top 5 have you been to? Get stamped.

Don’t miss

  • Club · Cherry Grove

    Ice Palace

    Long-running gay nightclub with drag, theme parties and the Miss Fire Island pageant.

  • Bar · Fire Island Pines

    The Blue Whale

    Where the Pines tea dance began. Daily Low Tea and weekend drag brunch.

  • Club · Fire Island Pines

    Pavilion

    The main Pines nightclub on the harbor, home of High Tea and show tune Sundays.

  • Bar · Cherry Grove

    Cherry's on the Bay

    Bayfront bar with drag most nights in season, a piano bar and drag brunch.

  • Community · Cherry Grove

    Arts Project of Cherry Grove

    Community arts group staging theater, drag and art at the historic Community House.

  • Beach · Cherry Grove

    Cherry Grove Beach

    Ocean beach of car-free Cherry Grove, a gay destination since the 1940s.

  • Club · Fire Island Pines

    Sip-n-Twirl

    Late-night Pines dance bar with a rooftop deck that picks up after the Pavilion winds down.

  • Hotel · Cherry Grove

    Belvedere Guest House for Men

    Bayfront men's guest house in Cherry Grove.

See all 13 places in Fire IslandEvery bar, club and more, on the map and in one list.

Gay neighborhoods in Fire Island

Gay Fire Island: questions people ask

Where is the gay area in Fire Island?
Most of our Fire Island listings are in Cherry Grove, with 8 places, including Cherry's on the Bay and Ice Palace. Fire Island Pines comes next, with 5.
Where can I see drag in Fire Island?
Cherry's on the Bay, Ice Palace and The Blue Whale all have drag on our listings.
Is there a gay beach in Fire Island?
Yes: Cherry Grove Beach and Fire Island Pines Beach.

Nearby on The Gays